The Concept of Nation: the Main Tends of Genesis in the 18th — early 20th Centuries in the Discourse of non-Marxist Paradigms

Article
Open Access
by Vyacheslav Vilkov1
1 Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv (Kyiv, Ukraine)
DOI: https://doi.org/10.29202/up/8/15
Received: 3 April 2021 / Accepted: 5 May 2021 / Published: 29 May 2021

View Full-Text Review Reports Cite This Paper

Abstract

In contrast to the approaches presented in the scientific literature, the article, based on a complex of methods (systematic, comparative, discursive and content analysis, prescriptions of scientism and the principle of historicism) of the humanities and social sciences, suggests the results of a system-oriented analysis of the evolution and transformations of the most influential meanings and senses of the concept «nation» used throughout the history of Europe and the world, which were theoretically developed in the philosophical and political thought, human sciences and political doctrines of the 18th — early 20th centuries for cognition, as well as ideological, legal and mental/psychological support of the two main ways of nation genesis and national-state building, in particular «from nation to state» and «from state to nation.» Historically, a large-scale scientific approach allowed to define the main stages and dominant trends in the development of interpretations of such national communities as cultural (ethnic) social groups and political (civil) communities, thus revealing their relationship with concepts, mythologems, and ideologems, such as «the people,» «national revival,» «the sovereignty of the people,» «national state,» «nationalism» and «patriotism.» Another scientific novelty of the article is the generalized presentation and theoretical evaluation in the context of the centuries-old genesis of the theoretical ideas about the nations, specifics of the Austro-Marxist approach of the early twentieth century.The material of the article may be particularly relevant for a scientifically balanced, ideologically unbiased, adequate understanding of the processes of development of philosophical, social, and political thought both in the Western world and in modern Ukraine since independence.

Keywords: people, nation, ethnic (cultural) nation, political (civil) nation, national state, nationalstat building

References

Bauer, Otto (1909) The Question of Nationalities and Social Democracy. St. Petersburg.
Collection of articles on the Russian Revolution S. A. Askoldov, N. A. Berdyaev, S. A. Bulgakov et al. (1990) Moscow: Publishing House of Moscow University. Available online: http://vehi.net/deprofundis/struve.html

Dunn, Otto (2003) Nations and Nationalism in Germany 1770-1990. St. Petersburg: «Science.»

Gellner, Ernest (2003) Nations and Nationalism; Nationalism. Kyiv, Taxon.

Habermas, Jürgen (2002) The European National State. Its Achievements and Its Limitations. On the Past and Future of Sovereignty and Citizenship. Nation and Nationalism. Moscow.: Praksis publishers.: 364–380.

Habermas, Jürgen (2001) The Inclusion of the Other: Studies in Political Theory. St. Petersburg, Nauka publishers.

In Latvia, people of other nationalities were prohibited to become Latvians (2021) Available online: http://www.belvpo.com/ru/74266.html

Knyazhinsky, Anton (1959) The spirit of the nation. Sociological-ethnopsychological studio. New York — Philadelphia — Munich: Science partnership im. Shevchenko.

Kozing, Alfred (1978) Nation in History and Modernity (A research held in connection with the historical-materialistic theory of the nation). Moscow: Progress publishing house.

Krysachenko, Valentin (2003) The mechanism of formation of classical political nations. Ukrainian political nation: genesis, state, prospects. Kyiv, NIDS, 70-78.

Politology: An Encyclopedic Dictionary (1993) Moscow: Moscow publishing house. The University of Commerce Publishing House.

Politology Encyclopedic Dictionary: higher educational establishment students manual (1997). Kyiv: Genesis.

Smith, Antony (2003) Nationalism and Modernism. Accessible online: http://milliyyet.info/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/Anthony-D.-Smith-Nationalism-and-Modernism.pdf

Springer, Rudolph (1909) National Problems: The Struggle of Nationalities in Austria. St. Petersburg.

Sorokin, Pitirim (1999) National question. Available online: http://www.srinest.com/book_843_chapter_24_PITIRIM_SOROKIN_INAIONALNYJJ_VOPROS.html

Starosolsky, Vladimir (1998) Theory of the nation. New York; Kyiv: Nauk. T. Shevchenko: Higher school.

Vilkov, Vyacheslav (2017) Axioms of the Political and Philosophical Model of Nation and Nation-State Building by Jürgen Habermas. Voprosy Filosofii, Vol. 2.: 5-17.

Vilkov, Vyacheslav (2014) Genesis of the notion of nation. 3rd edition. Kyiv: Published by Karpenko V. M.

Vilkov, Vyacheslav (2018) The Ideologeme and Mythologeme of the National Idea: Ukrainian Political and Philosophical Tradition in the Discourse of Modern Theory of Democracy (part two). Wspólpraca Europejska, Warszawa, Polska, Wydawca — Consilium Sp. z o.o. Vol. 5 (36): 9-22.

Vilkov, Vyacheslav and Sergey Rudenko (2019) The Modernization of the Russian Marxist Concept of the Nation in the Social Sciences and Humanities in the USSR in the Second Half of the Twentieth Century. Ukrainian Policymaker, Volume 4.: 69-84.

Vilkov, Vyacheslav and Alexander Kostenko (2016) Politico-philosophical and regulatory framework for the creation of civil nations and nation-states at the beginning of the modern era (part one). Wspólpraca Europejska, Warszawa, Polska, Wydawca — Consilium Sp. z o.o., 2016. ? 4 (11).: 62-93.

Vilkov, Vyacheslav and Alexander Kostenko (2016a) Politico-philosophical and regulatory framework for the creation of civil nations and nation-states at the beginning of the modern era (part two). Wspólpraca Europejska, Warszawa, Polska, Wydawca — Consilium Sp. z o.o., No. 5 (12).: 99-112.

Vilkov, Vyacheslav (2020) The Russian Marxist concept of the nation: Soviet deStalinization problems and the main trends of anti-Marxist revisionism in post-Soviet Ukraine. Research, challenges and development prospects in the area of social sciences: Collective monograph. Riga: Izdevniectba «Balija Publishing,» 36-68.

Vilkov, Vyacheslav (2017) Western Nationology of 20th Century: Conceptual Portraits. History of Nation and Nationalism Theories. Saarbrücken: Lambert Academic Publishing.

Share and Cite

Vilkov, Vyacheslav (2021) The Concept of Nation: the Main Tends of Genesis in the 18th — early 20th Centuries in the Discourse of non-Marxist Paradigms. Ukrainian Policymaker, Volume 8, 138-153. https://doi.org/10.29202/up/8/15
Back to the list of Articles