Charting A Distinctive Course: The Ukrainian Orthodox Church, Religious Pluralism, and Church-State Relations -

Article

Open Access

by Lincoln E. Flake¹
¹ Wolfson College, Cambridge University (Cambridge, England)
DOI: https://doi.org/10.29202/up/7/2
Received: 9 August 2020 / Accepted: 30 September 2020 / Published: 3 December 2020

View Full-Text Review Reports Cite This Paper

Abstract

The Ukrainian Orthodox Church has a chance to be an outlier in a region otherwise inhospitable to religious diversity. Less than two years after gaining autonomy in the Orthodox community, signs are promising that church elites are neither frightened by religious choice or inclined toward state sponsorship. Such a posture would contrast glaringly with the ethos of its once overseer, the Russian Orthodox Church. I argue that, although the church’s development is still embryonic, several factors suggest a more tolerant attitude toward the operations of other nontraditional may prove durable. Hopefully, the approach is not simply a matter of the church conforming to pro-democracy sentiments in Kyiv, but rather is rooted in experience and deep-seeded beliefs. If this proves to be the case, religious pluralism and constructive church-state relations has the chance to be irrevocably engrained in the country. Such a development would dispel the notion that Eastern Orthodoxy and authoritarianism are somehow inextricably connected. Even more importantly for Ukraine’s future, a modern and transparent national church may help anchor Kyiv to its current democratizing orientation, preventing a cyclical return to autocracy.

Keywords: Ukraine, Orthodox Church, religious pluralism, church-state relations, civil society

References

Bey, Ilya (2020) Ukrainian Orthodox Church 2019 — Results of the Year. Religious Information Service of Ukraine, January 2. Available online: https://risu.org.ua/en/index/expert_thought/analytic/78388/

Berger, Peter (2005) Orthodoxy and Global Pluralism. Article delivered at the conference «The Spirit of the Orthodoxy and the Ethic of Capitalism,» Vienna, Austria. Available online: http://demokratizatsiya. pub/archives/13_3_F22627251610N504.pdf

Brik, Tymofil and Stanislav Korolkov (2019) Religious Markets in Ukraine: Post-communist Revivals and New Directions. In Ukraine in Transformation. Edited by Alberto VeiraRamos, Tetian Liubyva and Evgenii Golovakha. Palgrave Macmillan. 145-165.

Denysenko, Nicholas (2018) The Orthodox Church in Ukraine: A Century of Separation. Northern Illinois University Press.

Druzenko, Gennadiy (2011) Religion and the Secular State in Ukraine. International Center for Law and Religion Studies 720. Available online: https://www.iclrs.org/content/blurb/files/Ukraine.1.pdf

Elsner, Regina (2019) Orthodox Church of Ukraine: Challenges and Risks of a New Beginning. Russian Analytical Digest, Volume 231, 9-13.

Flake, Lincoln and Jeremy Lamoreaux (2018) The Russian Orthodox Church, the Kremlin, and Religious (Il)Liberalism in Russia. Palgrave Communications, Volume 4. Available online: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41599-018-0169-6

Goble, Paul (2019) 520 parishes of Moscow Church have now shifted to autocephalous Orthodox Church of Ukraine. Euromaidan Press. July 31. Available online: http://euromaidanpress.com/2019/07/31/520-parishes-of-moscow-church-have-now-shiftedto-autocephalous-orthodox-church-of-ukraine/

Jianu, Daniel (2019) Symphonia and the Historical Relationship between State and Church: Legacies from Byzantine Times until Today. Orthodox Religion and Politics in Contemporary Eastern Europe. Edited by Tobias Koellner. Routledge.

Khodre, Georges (1971) Christianity in a Pluralistic World: The Economy of the Holy Spirit. The Ecumenical Review, Volume 23, 118-128.

Kuzio, Taras (2019) Old Wine in a New Bottle: Russia’s Modernization of Traditional Soviet Information Warfare and Active Policies Against Ukraine and Ukrainians. Journal of Slavic Military Studies, Volume 4, 485-506.

Ishchuk, Natalia and Oleksandr Sagan (2020) The Idea of a National Church in the Ukrainian Intellectual Discourse. Occasional Papers on Religion in Eastern Europe, Volume 40.

Ladouceur, Paul (2019) Modern Orthodox Theology. Bloomsbury.

Luxmoore, Jonathan (2019) New Ukraine church endures inter-Orthodox feud, but offers Catholics hope. Catholic Reporter. March 13. Available online: https://www.ncronline.org/news/people/new-ukraine-church-endures-inter-orthodox-feud-offers-catholicshope

Makrides, Vasilios (2020) Orthodox Christianity and Modern Human Rights: Theorizing Their Nexus and Addressing Orthodox Specificities. Global Eastern Orthodoxy: Politics, Religion, and Human Rights. Edited by Giuseppe Giordan and Siniša Zrinšcak. Springer, 59-76.

Olteanu, Tina and Dorothee de Neve (2014) Eastern Orthodoxy and the Processes of European Integration. In Eastern Orthodox Encounters of Identity and Otherness. Edited by Andreii Krawchuk and Thomas Bremer. Palgrave Macmillan, 179-199.

Pew (2019) A Closer Look at How Religious Restrictions Have Risen Around the World. July 15. Available online: https://www.pewforum.org/2019/07/15/a-closer-look-athow-religious-restrictions-have-risen-around-the-world/

Pollis, Adamantia (1993) Eastern Orthodoxy and Human Rights. Human Rights Quarterly, Volume 15, 339-356.

Prodromou, Elizabeth (2004) Christianity and Democracy: The Ambivalent Orthodox. Journal of Democracy, Volume 2, 62-75.

Radio Free Europe (2020) One-Third of Ukrainians Say They Belong To Church Independent Of Moscow. February 4. Available online: https://www.rferl.org/a/one-third-ofukrainians-say-they-belong-to-church-independent-of-moscow/30415952.html

Requena, Felix (2019) The Catholic Church and consolidation of democratic civil society in Spain. Journal of Civil Society, Volume 3, 249-266

RISU — Religious Information Service of Ukraine (2019a) OCU Primate Receives the Athenagoras Human Rights Award in the USA. October 20. Available online: https://risu.org.ua/en/index/all_news/orthodox/ocu/77511/

RISU — Religious Information Service of Ukraine (2019b) OCU Primate: We Will Implement Good Reforms and Shift Away from Russian Imperial Traditions. March 1. Available online: https://risu.org.ua/en/index/all_news/orth odox/ocu/74919/

Sagan, Oleksandr (2019) Constituting of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church as a Factor in Changing the Cultural-Civilizational Paradigm of Independent Ukraine. Ukrainian Religious Studies, Volume 88, 23-38.

Smytsnyuk, Pavlo (2019) The Autocephaly of the Orthodox Church of Ukraine: Ecumenical Perspectives. Religious Information Service of Ukraine, November 25. Available online: https://risu.org.ua/en/index/monitoring/soc iety_digest/77932/

Stoeckl, Kristina (2009) Community after Totalitarianism: The Russian Orthodox Intellectual Tradition and Philosophical Discourse of Political Modernity. Peter Lang.

Stoeckl, Kristina (2020) The Russian Orthodox Church’s Approach to Human Rights. In Global Eastern Orthodoxy: Politics, Religion, and Human Rights. Edited by Giuseppe Giordan and Siniša Zrinšcak. Springer, 59-76.

Yannoulatos, Anastasios (2003) Toward a Global Community: Resources and Responsibilities. In Facing the World: Orthodox Christian Essays on Global Concerns. St. Vladimir’s Seminar Press, 15-47.

Share and Cite

Flake, Lincoln (2020) Charting A Distinctive Course: The Ukrainian Orthodox Church, Religious Pluralism, and Church-State Relations. Ukrainian Policymaker, Volume 7, 13-19. https://doi.org/10.29202/up/7/2

Back to the list of Articles